Zack; I was pretty apprehensive of this album. On the
one hand, there are things like the title or the artwork or the names of the
songs. On the other, I kind of like the few Marilyn Manson songs I’ve
encountered in the wild (namely Beautiful People and Vampire) and I remember
watching Bowling for Columbine when I was a kid and seeing Marilyn Manson be
probably the most thoughtful and articulate person in that whole documentary (I
rewatched that interview before I wrote this and it still kind of holds up, especially
the part where he says “I wouldn’t say anything to [the people of the Columbine
High School community], I would listen to them because it’s the one thing that
no one did.”) Both of those points gave me hope. I found that the album
confirmed that my reasons for hope were right. While I was listening to it, I
was reminded of this band that I’ve gotten kind of into in the past few years,
Deafheaven. In terms of general sound, there really aren’t that many
similarities. But what I like about Deafheave is how well produced the
rollicking metal riffs and screeching sound. It’s metal, but it sounds really
lush. The production on Antichrist Superstar was comparable in that sense. Even
if this album growled where Deafheaven tend to scream, there was a richness to
the music that was really impressive. I don’t think I’ll ever get really into
it, and I probably won’t ever listen to it again (when I crave metal, which is
rarely, I usually just rotate between the aforementioned Deafheaven and early
Metallica, and I’m content with not branching out much from there). But it’s
certainly worth a listen, even for the less thrashy among us.
Favorite Tracks: The Beautiful People; Antichrist Superstar;
Tourniquet
Emily: I always associate Marilyn Manson with his cover of Personal Jesus by Depeche Mode. For the longest time, I thought that was his song, not a cover. Even when I hear the original I always assume it's the Marilyn Manson version. Before today, I'm not sure if I had even heard any of Manson's own songs. Personal Jesus is certainly more approachable to an unaccustomed listener (like me) than most of Antichrist Superstar, but I liked this album more than I thought it would. Yes, it has its moments of disorienting anger and distortion, and it's about 20 minutes too long, but there's grandiose performance and melody surrounding it all. And it just works, better than I thought it could.
Favorite Tracks: The Beautiful People; Angel with the Scabbed Wings; Tourniquet